New Marketing Blog - NetMarketing
Stumbled accross this new marketing blog called NetMarketing by Robert Lock via the Corante Blog. Lots of industry info.
BTW just added a discussion forum via Bravenet (thanks to NetMarketing). So talk it up folks ...
April 08, 2002
Adweak: Ad Criticism & Blatantly Fake News
Thought of making a parody website of Adweek. Looks like someone already did. Pretty funny site. Check it out.
Thought of making a parody website of Adweek. Looks like someone already did. Pretty funny site. Check it out.
Totalitarian Control of the Browser - First Our Inboxes, Now our Browsers
Sean Carton gives another scary view of things to come in his latest ClickZ article at what some marketers are trying to do to our browsers. The sad thing is, I think Sean is dead on with this prediction.
Sean Carton gives another scary view of things to come in his latest ClickZ article at what some marketers are trying to do to our browsers. The sad thing is, I think Sean is dead on with this prediction.
April 02, 2002
Ads that People Want
In an advertising world where 2% responses are something the cheer about ....
Media Central's Media Buyer's Daily reports on a study by Knowledge Networks/Statistical Research Inc which found "73% of consumers surveyed said yellow pages ads are more important than other ad types because they 'provide information at the time of purchase'.... Local and national yellow pages advertising generated 13.6 billion in revenue in 2001."
See, sometimes useful things aren't quite so sexy.
Marketing that a customer wants is marketing that works.
In an advertising world where 2% responses are something the cheer about ....
Media Central's Media Buyer's Daily reports on a study by Knowledge Networks/Statistical Research Inc which found "73% of consumers surveyed said yellow pages ads are more important than other ad types because they 'provide information at the time of purchase'.... Local and national yellow pages advertising generated 13.6 billion in revenue in 2001."
See, sometimes useful things aren't quite so sexy.
Marketing that a customer wants is marketing that works.
March 26, 2002
Arbitron tells CARP to go Scratch
This is HUGE. The fact that the Nielson ratings of radio has come out against CARP's recommendation is going to make this one a real fight ...
More here.
This is HUGE. The fact that the Nielson ratings of radio has come out against CARP's recommendation is going to make this one a real fight ...
NEW YORK, March 25, 2002 -Arbitron Inc. provided congressional leaders with detailed reasons why they should oppose the digital rights fees recommended by the Copyright Arbitration Royalty Panel (CARP) and, instead, institute a five-year moratorium on such fees for streaming media.
"We foresee that the impact of these fees will dramatically reduce the consumer's choice of streaming content, limit the diversity of streaming 'voices' on the Internet, stifle competition among content providers and impede the growth of a popular new medium," wrote Bill Rose, vice president and general manager, Arbitron Webcast Services, in letters to members of Congress.
More here.
Free to Fee?
This is a question of been pondering for a while. I think Andy Bourland hits the head in his renewed column on ClickZ.
Those offering superior to none content will thrive in this model. Those offering information that's a commodity will fail. Regardless I think just as it was foolish to rely on just ad revenue to keep a site up and running, it would be foolish to rely only on paid subscriptions.
I've got an idea buzzing in my head (see last few entries) about introducing blogging as a source of income. Stay tuned ....
This is a question of been pondering for a while. I think Andy Bourland hits the head in his renewed column on ClickZ.
Moving from "free" to "fee" is risky. If you offer content that's simply "nice to have" rather than "vital to have," chances are your audience won't pay you a dime. If you have a bunch of competitors offering similar content for free, you're not likely to succeed in charging for what your readers can get elsewhere for nothing. If your audience is ill-defined or if the solutions you offer are only a modest improvement over the status quo, they won't open their wallets, either.
Those offering superior to none content will thrive in this model. Those offering information that's a commodity will fail. Regardless I think just as it was foolish to rely on just ad revenue to keep a site up and running, it would be foolish to rely only on paid subscriptions.
I've got an idea buzzing in my head (see last few entries) about introducing blogging as a source of income. Stay tuned ....
March 19, 2002
Fast Company on Blogging
Blogging is starting to tip. First MSNBC, now Fast Company gives us their take on blogging ...
Blog Journalism: "Say good-bye to the old-school pundits on the op-ed page of the New York Times. It's time to blog."
Blogs Demassifying: (although I think this author misses many beats, it translates well for those still living in a mass-broadcast world) " Weblogs aren't just glorified pages of links and rambling personal sites; they are an antidote to mass media."
Fast Company contributor's blogs here. And their list of favorite blogs here.
This popularization of blogging is a little scary. I need to complete my ideas on using blogging for business before some dinosaur makes a mess of it all.
Blogging is starting to tip. First MSNBC, now Fast Company gives us their take on blogging ...
Blog Journalism: "Say good-bye to the old-school pundits on the op-ed page of the New York Times. It's time to blog."
Peer groups organize themselves in hundreds of different ways. But what they all have in common is a shared sense of mission: what the military calls "unit cohesion." That cohesion -- a kind of network effect -- is what makes the peer group, or team, much stronger than the simple sum of its parts .....
They call themselves "Webloggers" -- or "bloggers," for short -- and they're providing the most energetic, lively, and passionate analysis, commentary, and opinion around....
When they're not focused on themselves, mainstream journalists spend most of their time sucking up to sources and writing with a keen eye toward source protection. Bloggers spend most of their time engaged in constant communication with their readers. In so doing, they create a network of sources who are always on the lookout for interesting articles, columns, stories, and items.
Blogs Demassifying: (although I think this author misses many beats, it translates well for those still living in a mass-broadcast world) " Weblogs aren't just glorified pages of links and rambling personal sites; they are an antidote to mass media."
"A Weblog is based entirely on trust," she says. "People come because they like to read what you write. If you suddenly began promoting Nokia cell phones on the side, news of it would come out quickly because this is a close-knit community. And that would be a tremendous breach of trust. It would be a scandal in the Weblog community because it goes against our entire ethic."
Fast Company contributor's blogs here. And their list of favorite blogs here.
This popularization of blogging is a little scary. I need to complete my ideas on using blogging for business before some dinosaur makes a mess of it all.
March 15, 2002
Bloggers in a Dot Bomb World
Henry Jenkins has written two (similar) pieces (here and here) on the increasing popularity and importance of blogging.
What I really like about Jenkins' pieces is how he melds blogging and mainstream media: Mainstream media will help shape our nation's common values, principles and core issues and the web (via blogging) will reframe those messages for specific segments and communities ....": turn on the TV and it feels like the same programs are on all the channels; turn to the Web and it’s impossible to distinguish the good stuff from the noise. Bloggers respond to both extremes, expanding the range of perspectives and, if they’re clever, creating order from the informational chaos."
I think Jenkins' articles go beyond some of the beliefs in the blogging community that the broadcast/mainstream media will die out and be replaced with a world of loosley joined pieces (for a kids explanation, which is also great for some grownups check here). While we live in a world where we can connect to someone thousands of miles away, we are still connected to our neighbors and our physical communities. The irony is that broadcast will maintain the consistency in values among neighbors while the web will diversify our culture and empower us to follow our passions and gain alternate perspectives on the physical world, like politics, sports, business ideas, and other issues and topics.
Blogging For Businesses .....
How does business use blogging? I've got some solid ideas. And they begin with David Weinberger's idea that customers (should) "own" a business' web site. And it continues with Chris Locke's idea in Gonzo Marketing that companies should underwrite websites that express common interests of the company's customers and employees.
Except my idea doesn't keep the underwritten web site separate from the company's web site. Instead, a community of bloggers (of both employees and customers), is hosted and promoted on the company's web site. Those who hold passions revolving around a company's product or service can discuss that passion within a community of bloggers on the company's web site.
The blogs will still be "owned" by the blog's creators while maintaining autonomy, similar to how one hosts their blog on Blog Spot. However the host will reflect a more niche community. For example, my blog on Guitar World Magazine's web site could be http://scottmusic.guitarworldblog.com. If I offer similar, but non-competing service, or content, and have gained the popularity to do so effectively (like Chris Locke has done in his community), Guitar World will underwrite my web site, promote it, etc. In return I link back to Guitar World's web site, and I send them leads.
Henry Jenkins has written two (similar) pieces (here and here) on the increasing popularity and importance of blogging.
What I really like about Jenkins' pieces is how he melds blogging and mainstream media: Mainstream media will help shape our nation's common values, principles and core issues and the web (via blogging) will reframe those messages for specific segments and communities ....": turn on the TV and it feels like the same programs are on all the channels; turn to the Web and it’s impossible to distinguish the good stuff from the noise. Bloggers respond to both extremes, expanding the range of perspectives and, if they’re clever, creating order from the informational chaos."
I think Jenkins' articles go beyond some of the beliefs in the blogging community that the broadcast/mainstream media will die out and be replaced with a world of loosley joined pieces (for a kids explanation, which is also great for some grownups check here). While we live in a world where we can connect to someone thousands of miles away, we are still connected to our neighbors and our physical communities. The irony is that broadcast will maintain the consistency in values among neighbors while the web will diversify our culture and empower us to follow our passions and gain alternate perspectives on the physical world, like politics, sports, business ideas, and other issues and topics.
Blogging For Businesses .....
How does business use blogging? I've got some solid ideas. And they begin with David Weinberger's idea that customers (should) "own" a business' web site. And it continues with Chris Locke's idea in Gonzo Marketing that companies should underwrite websites that express common interests of the company's customers and employees.
Except my idea doesn't keep the underwritten web site separate from the company's web site. Instead, a community of bloggers (of both employees and customers), is hosted and promoted on the company's web site. Those who hold passions revolving around a company's product or service can discuss that passion within a community of bloggers on the company's web site.
The blogs will still be "owned" by the blog's creators while maintaining autonomy, similar to how one hosts their blog on Blog Spot. However the host will reflect a more niche community. For example, my blog on Guitar World Magazine's web site could be http://scottmusic.guitarworldblog.com. If I offer similar, but non-competing service, or content, and have gained the popularity to do so effectively (like Chris Locke has done in his community), Guitar World will underwrite my web site, promote it, etc. In return I link back to Guitar World's web site, and I send them leads.
March 14, 2002
Bloggers in a Dot Bomb World
Henry Jenkins has written two (similar) pieces, on MSNBC and MIT Technology Review (here and here) on the increasing popularity and importance of blogging.
What I really like about Jenkins' pieces is how he melds blogging and mainstream media: Mainstream media will help shape our nation's common values, principles and core issues and the web (via blogging) will reframe those messages for specific segments and communities ....": turn on the TV and it feels like the same programs are on all the channels; turn to the Web and it’s impossible to distinguish the good stuff from the noise. Bloggers respond to both extremes, expanding the range of perspectives and, if they’re clever, creating order from the informational chaos."
I think Jenkins' articles go beyond some of the beliefs in the blogging community that the broadcast/mainstream media will die out and be replaced with a world of loosley joined pieces (for a kids explanation, which is also great for some grownups check here). While we live in a world where we can connect to someone thousands of miles away, we are still connected to our neighbors and our physical communities. The irony is that broadcast will maintain the consistency in values among neighbors while the web will diversify our culture and empower us to follow our passions and gain alternate perspectives on the physical world, like politics, sports, business ideas, and other issues and topics.
Blogging For Businesses .....
How does business use blogging? I've got some solid ideas. And they begin with David Weinberger's idea that customers (should) "own" a business' web site. And it continues with Chris Locke's idea in Gonzo Marketing that companies should underwrite websites that express common interests of the company's customers and employees.
Except my idea doesn't keep the underwritten web site separate from the company's web site. Instead, a community of bloggers (of both employees and customers), is hosted and promoted on the company's web site. Those who hold passions revolving around a company's product or service can discuss that passion within a community of bloggers on the company's web site.
The blogs will still be "owned" by the blog's creators while maintaining autonomy, similar to how one hosts their blog on Blog Spot. However the host will reflect a more niche community. For example, my blog on Guitar World Magazine's web site could be http://scottmusic.guitarworldblog.com. If I offer similar, but non-competing service, or content, and have gained the popularity to do so effectively (like Chris Locke has done in his community), Guitar World will underwrite my web site, promote it, etc. In return I link back to Guitar World's web site, and I send them leads.
Henry Jenkins has written two (similar) pieces, on MSNBC and MIT Technology Review (here and here) on the increasing popularity and importance of blogging.
What I really like about Jenkins' pieces is how he melds blogging and mainstream media: Mainstream media will help shape our nation's common values, principles and core issues and the web (via blogging) will reframe those messages for specific segments and communities ....": turn on the TV and it feels like the same programs are on all the channels; turn to the Web and it’s impossible to distinguish the good stuff from the noise. Bloggers respond to both extremes, expanding the range of perspectives and, if they’re clever, creating order from the informational chaos."
I think Jenkins' articles go beyond some of the beliefs in the blogging community that the broadcast/mainstream media will die out and be replaced with a world of loosley joined pieces (for a kids explanation, which is also great for some grownups check here). While we live in a world where we can connect to someone thousands of miles away, we are still connected to our neighbors and our physical communities. The irony is that broadcast will maintain the consistency in values among neighbors while the web will diversify our culture and empower us to follow our passions and gain alternate perspectives on the physical world, like politics, sports, business ideas, and other issues and topics.
Blogging For Businesses .....
How does business use blogging? I've got some solid ideas. And they begin with David Weinberger's idea that customers (should) "own" a business' web site. And it continues with Chris Locke's idea in Gonzo Marketing that companies should underwrite websites that express common interests of the company's customers and employees.
Except my idea doesn't keep the underwritten web site separate from the company's web site. Instead, a community of bloggers (of both employees and customers), is hosted and promoted on the company's web site. Those who hold passions revolving around a company's product or service can discuss that passion within a community of bloggers on the company's web site.
The blogs will still be "owned" by the blog's creators while maintaining autonomy, similar to how one hosts their blog on Blog Spot. However the host will reflect a more niche community. For example, my blog on Guitar World Magazine's web site could be http://scottmusic.guitarworldblog.com. If I offer similar, but non-competing service, or content, and have gained the popularity to do so effectively (like Chris Locke has done in his community), Guitar World will underwrite my web site, promote it, etc. In return I link back to Guitar World's web site, and I send them leads.
March 13, 2002
The Tipping Blog
Very cool and interesting follow up piece from John Hiler at Corante ... Malcom Gladwell's Tipping Point is used to explain the potently viral element of the internet. Which explains why Rob Poel saw that everyone else had already blogged John's earlier article on why google loves blogs.
An interesting exerpt:
Very cool and interesting follow up piece from John Hiler at Corante ... Malcom Gladwell's Tipping Point is used to explain the potently viral element of the internet. Which explains why Rob Poel saw that everyone else had already blogged John's earlier article on why google loves blogs.
An interesting exerpt:
Understanding how Link Mavens and Connectors work transformed my thoughts of how ideas spread. You can literally see the process take place online in a way that is virtually impossible in real life.
It's generally a five-step process:
1. An Expert (one might call her a Content Maven) Writes or Creates something interesting and puts it online (creating the critical component of any online ideavirus: the link)
2. A Link Maven comes across the link, and blogs it to their site
3. A Connector finds the link and blogs it to their site (or the aforementioned Link Maven has Connector-like traffic levels)
4. The link starts to Tip within the weblog community
5. The link Tips beyond the weblog community, as the rest of us find out about it
Advertisers think about banner-ad campaigns as a way to carpetbomb their audience with ads. But in a world where ideas and links can Tip so dramatically, perhaps it makes sense for them to revise their thinking.
March 12, 2002
ESPN Goes to Washington
This is why the baseball, Jagr and the Wiz will never rule this town. Why Steve Spurrier is the Rageboy of sports. The past DC'er's cling to, without relent. And the real men with a say in this town.
This is why the baseball, Jagr and the Wiz will never rule this town. Why Steve Spurrier is the Rageboy of sports. The past DC'er's cling to, without relent. And the real men with a say in this town.
March 07, 2002
Amateur Journalism Ruled Equal
This is a great win for Free Speech and Blog Journalism. From Doc. Anyone know where I can get a copy of the ruling?
This is a great win for Free Speech and Blog Journalism. From Doc. Anyone know where I can get a copy of the ruling?
March 04, 2002
I Changed My Name
"Hyper-Conversations" was ... well .... kinda lame, and not entirely me. Plus this ties in with a web site which I'll have completed more sooner than later (www.web-sense.com) which will market ... myself.
"Hyper-Conversations" was ... well .... kinda lame, and not entirely me. Plus this ties in with a web site which I'll have completed more sooner than later (www.web-sense.com) which will market ... myself.
February 27, 2002
"When you cut out the bullshit, what's left of marketing?"
Doc points us to this oldy but goody in response to the conversation on the Dvorak piece (of crap) on Cluetrain. Also, I can't go without pointing you to Cluetrain co-author Chris Locke's eloquent response to the article. Dvoraks pitiful rebutle. And RB's response.
Doc points us to this oldy but goody in response to the conversation on the Dvorak piece (of crap) on Cluetrain. Also, I can't go without pointing you to Cluetrain co-author Chris Locke's eloquent response to the article. Dvoraks pitiful rebutle. And RB's response.
February 26, 2002
From David Weinberger in a Fast Company Interview: Web Sites Need to Belong to the Customers
"The biggest mistake that most companies make is to think that a Web site belongs to them. Companies just don't get it. Individuals believe that the Web belongs to us. ... On the Web, companies can only control the conversation by being interesting -- and most corporations are afraid of being interesting."
"Most important, I'd avoid the temptation to think of my Web site as mine. Look at the Royal Dutch/Shell site [www.shell.com]. There, visitors can engage in online conversations on a wide range of social issues. Many of the comments are critical of the company, but Shell doesn't interfere. The company understands that it can't own the Web. In a way, that's a huge -- and rare -- leap forward."
I can't get this out of my head: "A company's web site should belong to its customers." This just makes so much sense. I think I feel a Paradigm Shift coming on. Look out!
"The biggest mistake that most companies make is to think that a Web site belongs to them. Companies just don't get it. Individuals believe that the Web belongs to us. ... On the Web, companies can only control the conversation by being interesting -- and most corporations are afraid of being interesting."
"Most important, I'd avoid the temptation to think of my Web site as mine. Look at the Royal Dutch/Shell site [www.shell.com]. There, visitors can engage in online conversations on a wide range of social issues. Many of the comments are critical of the company, but Shell doesn't interfere. The company understands that it can't own the Web. In a way, that's a huge -- and rare -- leap forward."
I can't get this out of my head: "A company's web site should belong to its customers." This just makes so much sense. I think I feel a Paradigm Shift coming on. Look out!
February 22, 2002
Advertising After the Revolution
Rageboy points us to this verycool piece and this piece too on the Cluetrain list. Give yourself 10 minutes and some speakers and enjoy.
If you like those, taste these here.
Rageboy points us to this verycool piece and this piece too on the Cluetrain list. Give yourself 10 minutes and some speakers and enjoy.
If you like those, taste these here.
February 20, 2002
Google Enhances Ad Offering
Google has made it's relevant advertising a little more relevant. Ever notice how when Google adds something to it repertoire, it's always really, really neat?
Google has made it's relevant advertising a little more relevant. Ever notice how when Google adds something to it repertoire, it's always really, really neat?
February 19, 2002
Is Advertising Dead? Adweek's Jack Feuer, Gonzo and Cluetrain
My December 3rd issue of Adweek has been sitting on top of my dresser for the past couple months folded (now permanently) to an op-ed that brings up a feeling I get reading Cluetrain and Gonzo.
The feeling is ... do exceptional advertising professionals already use the same concepts written about in Cluetrain and Gonzo? Are we just frustrated at the advertising junk which increasingly pervades our lives while not recognizing true advertising ingenuity and greatness? Because I think ingenuity and greatness in advertising is out there.
Within Reach: Looking for people, not their demographics or lifestyles. The author is Jack Feuer. (Sorry no link, Adweek doesn't keep an archive online). This is how the story goes:
Jack's revelation occured while sitting behind a Land Rover with tinted windows. The truck had a sticker most have seen: That snarling kid taking a whiz. The Land Rover and pisser sticker juxtaposed, Jack reflected. Why doesn't a lot of advertising work?
Jack writes:
Jack gives us an example of himself. Jack's demographic makes him out to be the bar hopping type. But Jack's really a huge Buffy fan...
And this is where I think Jack takes an interesting turn. Instead of saying, "go out and buy Gonzo Marketing to learn how to converse within the micromarketplace," he says "Perhaps media people ought to act a little more like creatives. Get out on the street. Talk to people. Pay more attention to the 'outlyers' on both ends of the tabulation charts. Barrow some account planning tricks."
Or transform "advertisers" to the real people in the corporation. Let them talk to the customers. Underwrite sites of common interest. --- alright, Jack didn't write this last part.
One of the things that kept tugging at my conscience while reading Gonzo Marketing were the role of Account Planners and exceptional creatives in creating effective advertising in the age of the web. They don't talk in "corporate-speak." For example, Nick Usborne isn't breaking any companies, he's writing great copy for the web. Just like great copywriters have written great copy for great ads for over a century. I don't think every (qualified) individual in an entire corporation has to start communicating with the outside world for corporate communication (FKA advertising) on the web to be effective, as Gonzo suggests.
Good advertisers need to understand how the web works. Know how it empowers customers. How customers are people. Not demographics. Not targets. Not to be marketed to.
Gonzo teaches us many things. Primarily, broadcast doesn't work on the web. Also, people are talking in micromarkets on the web. They are smarter and more cynical about advertising. But I think Gonzo is a tactic to be used. It's not the system's new replacement.
My December 3rd issue of Adweek has been sitting on top of my dresser for the past couple months folded (now permanently) to an op-ed that brings up a feeling I get reading Cluetrain and Gonzo.
The feeling is ... do exceptional advertising professionals already use the same concepts written about in Cluetrain and Gonzo? Are we just frustrated at the advertising junk which increasingly pervades our lives while not recognizing true advertising ingenuity and greatness? Because I think ingenuity and greatness in advertising is out there.
Within Reach: Looking for people, not their demographics or lifestyles. The author is Jack Feuer. (Sorry no link, Adweek doesn't keep an archive online). This is how the story goes:
Jack's revelation occured while sitting behind a Land Rover with tinted windows. The truck had a sticker most have seen: That snarling kid taking a whiz. The Land Rover and pisser sticker juxtaposed, Jack reflected. Why doesn't a lot of advertising work?
Jack writes:
Advertisers know all about fragmented media. They don't know enough about fragmented consumers .... [Advertisers] change us the same way they have changed the media.
For sure, they recognize that we have endless choices. That we are in control of the ever-multiplying array of media we are exposed to every day. But what's needed is real insight into how that choice and control change us. [personally, for that insight I recommend reading Cluetrain and Gonzo Marketing].
They change us the same way the have changed the media. We are demassified.
This, of course, is why marketing to demographics doesn't work as efficiently anymore. But the obvious response to that--crafting media plans and creative based on lifestyles--is equally futile. Because each of us is now a market of one."
Jack gives us an example of himself. Jack's demographic makes him out to be the bar hopping type. But Jack's really a huge Buffy fan...
If you knew me as a demassified individual, as a market of one, you'd forget my penchant for dimly lit bars and bad scotch. You'd ignore the gray in my hair and the extra pounds. You'd advertise on a TV show only 12-34s are supposed to like.
All the talk about relationship marketing and one-to-one communication is just vapor, because those concepts are mostly honored in the breach.
With all the vaunted technology that advertising brings to bear, we still haven't really figured out how to reach people as individuals. How to reach them through their minds instead of their demographics or their lifestyles. Through what they care about instead of what they're supposed to care about.
Optimizers won't do it. Focus groups are mostly just exercises in creative collective lying.
And this is where I think Jack takes an interesting turn. Instead of saying, "go out and buy Gonzo Marketing to learn how to converse within the micromarketplace," he says "Perhaps media people ought to act a little more like creatives. Get out on the street. Talk to people. Pay more attention to the 'outlyers' on both ends of the tabulation charts. Barrow some account planning tricks."
Or transform "advertisers" to the real people in the corporation. Let them talk to the customers. Underwrite sites of common interest. --- alright, Jack didn't write this last part.
One of the things that kept tugging at my conscience while reading Gonzo Marketing were the role of Account Planners and exceptional creatives in creating effective advertising in the age of the web. They don't talk in "corporate-speak." For example, Nick Usborne isn't breaking any companies, he's writing great copy for the web. Just like great copywriters have written great copy for great ads for over a century. I don't think every (qualified) individual in an entire corporation has to start communicating with the outside world for corporate communication (FKA advertising) on the web to be effective, as Gonzo suggests.
Good advertisers need to understand how the web works. Know how it empowers customers. How customers are people. Not demographics. Not targets. Not to be marketed to.
Gonzo teaches us many things. Primarily, broadcast doesn't work on the web. Also, people are talking in micromarkets on the web. They are smarter and more cynical about advertising. But I think Gonzo is a tactic to be used. It's not the system's new replacement.
February 15, 2002
Blogging and Journalism
I've read a lot recently on comparisons between blogging and journalism. I never made the connection until I read Doc's blog today.
What's wrong with Journalism today? As Deborah Branscum, a contributing editor to Newsweek and a contributor to Fortune.com's Valley Talk column, alludes to in her blog, journalism has become "the space between the advertisements, which pay for the entire operation." She continues describing how journalists only know what they're told, which is often one company's spin on how they want to position themselves ... and in worse case scenarios flat out lies to cover up scandal (i.e. Enron).
Blogging on the other hand, like Doc points out, allows individuals to tell stories as they see it. Not as what they're told to say. Because blogging is so personal, not influenced by ad revenue (or any outside revenue/pressure for that matter), but projects one's true passions and visions, more truth is seen in in blogging. And truth is the ultimate goal of journalism. Doc even goes further and says the conversation--the give and take of blogging--produces more authentic truths:
We're all sources for each other here, and don't have the pressures of space, deadlines or formats to restrict who we source or the stories they tell. Here we can vet ideas about what might be true, in faith that others who know more will correct us, or pick up the story and carry it forward.
Blogs are thickly woven into the web of what we know, what we want to know more about and how we inform each other. That makes them vastly different from the information distribution system that constitutes Journalism as Usual.
On the Web, we are not distributors of Information. What we give and gain is not a commodity. It's what we know. And when we share what we know, we get improved knowledge and far more well-qualified opinions.
Journalists blogs will become a great source of information. My question for the audience is (all one of you), does the public in general realize and care about the pressures from ad revenue and limited sources? Will they become tuned in to blogging? Or will it seem to the Bud Light drinking, Friends watching, NASCAR loving typical American like some weird internet thing for techie geeks? How and how quickly can the masses become engaged with blogging as a source of information?
I've read a lot recently on comparisons between blogging and journalism. I never made the connection until I read Doc's blog today.
What's wrong with Journalism today? As Deborah Branscum, a contributing editor to Newsweek and a contributor to Fortune.com's Valley Talk column, alludes to in her blog, journalism has become "the space between the advertisements, which pay for the entire operation." She continues describing how journalists only know what they're told, which is often one company's spin on how they want to position themselves ... and in worse case scenarios flat out lies to cover up scandal (i.e. Enron).
Blogging on the other hand, like Doc points out, allows individuals to tell stories as they see it. Not as what they're told to say. Because blogging is so personal, not influenced by ad revenue (or any outside revenue/pressure for that matter), but projects one's true passions and visions, more truth is seen in in blogging. And truth is the ultimate goal of journalism. Doc even goes further and says the conversation--the give and take of blogging--produces more authentic truths:
We're all sources for each other here, and don't have the pressures of space, deadlines or formats to restrict who we source or the stories they tell. Here we can vet ideas about what might be true, in faith that others who know more will correct us, or pick up the story and carry it forward.
Blogs are thickly woven into the web of what we know, what we want to know more about and how we inform each other. That makes them vastly different from the information distribution system that constitutes Journalism as Usual.
On the Web, we are not distributors of Information. What we give and gain is not a commodity. It's what we know. And when we share what we know, we get improved knowledge and far more well-qualified opinions.
Journalists blogs will become a great source of information. My question for the audience is (all one of you), does the public in general realize and care about the pressures from ad revenue and limited sources? Will they become tuned in to blogging? Or will it seem to the Bud Light drinking, Friends watching, NASCAR loving typical American like some weird internet thing for techie geeks? How and how quickly can the masses become engaged with blogging as a source of information?
February 08, 2002
Brainstorm Better
Just something very practical from MarketingProfs. Though some of this might seem obvious, we sometimes need a refresher because of all the deadlines we're under and the expected reactions we obsessively anticipate from clients.
Just something very practical from MarketingProfs. Though some of this might seem obvious, we sometimes need a refresher because of all the deadlines we're under and the expected reactions we obsessively anticipate from clients.
February 05, 2002
EGR: Watching the Detectives
Where to start??? And how ironic. I'm seriously chuckling. Big brother is watching, and look what they snagged. My employer, like many, has decided to start using software to monitor emails coming into my inbox. Looks for "dirty" words. Literally. This is the message I received:
-----Original Message-----
From: spamadminit@.com [mailto:spamadminit@.com]
Sent: Tuesday, February 05, 2002 9:18 PM
To: "ScottKnowles@mail..com"
Subject: Dirty Words_Notify
************* eManager Notification **************
*****Your message was trapped due to foul language. Please contact the sender of the message and have them remove the offending word and resend. Please refrain from future use of foul language to prevent your messages from being trapped again. *****
Now this wasn't one of the hundreds of peda-porno-necro sleeze ball spamo email messages I have received at my work email address over the past year. It was the latest enstallment from EGR. Of the 2,952 words that so brilliantly, intelligently and informatively appear in the text, a whopping 2 fit one's definition of "dirty words." (Don't get me wrong, I don't claim to understand 2,245 of those words, but somehow it all jives together) I do have to disclaim: I typically don't receive any Locke related email at work (I know better than that), but email problems at Excite (which, I must say, they handled extremely well considering the crap they had to put up with) forced me to make a temporary change.
One final thought: The irony of the title of Locke's latest send, "Watching the Detectives." I think it's time we start watching the detectives.
Where to start??? And how ironic. I'm seriously chuckling. Big brother is watching, and look what they snagged. My employer, like many, has decided to start using software to monitor emails coming into my inbox. Looks for "dirty" words. Literally. This is the message I received:
-----Original Message-----
From: spamadminit@.com [mailto:spamadminit@.com]
Sent: Tuesday, February 05, 2002 9:18 PM
To: "ScottKnowles@mail..com"
Subject: Dirty Words_Notify
************* eManager Notification **************
*****Your message was trapped due to foul language. Please contact the sender of the message and have them remove the offending word and resend. Please refrain from future use of foul language to prevent your messages from being trapped again. *****
Now this wasn't one of the hundreds of peda-porno-necro sleeze ball spamo email messages I have received at my work email address over the past year. It was the latest enstallment from EGR. Of the 2,952 words that so brilliantly, intelligently and informatively appear in the text, a whopping 2 fit one's definition of "dirty words." (Don't get me wrong, I don't claim to understand 2,245 of those words, but somehow it all jives together) I do have to disclaim: I typically don't receive any Locke related email at work (I know better than that), but email problems at Excite (which, I must say, they handled extremely well considering the crap they had to put up with) forced me to make a temporary change.
One final thought: The irony of the title of Locke's latest send, "Watching the Detectives." I think it's time we start watching the detectives.
January 25, 2002
KFFL Case Study
Content Biz from MarketingSherpa provides a great case study on a business model that works. KFFL is an online fantasy football site that has become one of the best NFL news sites on the web. The case study even claims pro-trainers and scouts use the site because it's so up to date. A mix of subscription fees and ad revenue keeps them up and very successful. Text ads dominate and advertisers get calls from KFFL if their ads suck and need to be changed. Some advertisers have been loyal for years.
Content Biz from MarketingSherpa provides a great case study on a business model that works. KFFL is an online fantasy football site that has become one of the best NFL news sites on the web. The case study even claims pro-trainers and scouts use the site because it's so up to date. A mix of subscription fees and ad revenue keeps them up and very successful. Text ads dominate and advertisers get calls from KFFL if their ads suck and need to be changed. Some advertisers have been loyal for years.
January 24, 2002
Charles Munat on Design
Charles Munat creates a compelling vision of web design. Charles argues that designers are stuck in control mode. All forms of creativity before the digital age were in a fixed space. The designer always had the illusion of controlling the design. But as Charles points out, that was never the case. Every creation has never truly replicated the designers intended presentation. Films in crappy theatres (one of my favorites), paintings with unintended lighting and muted TV commercials. What makes the internet different is it is truly interactive. It has the potential to illuminate the control put on viewers. It puts the audience and the creator in a conversation where the experience for the audience (or users) is truly democratic. Or so Charles would argue.
Or is this a pipe dream. I think the web makes this more possible. But not entirely possible. The designer is always in a sense going to control the user's experience. Every designer has a vision. And, I think, by definition that means they want to control how the audience views his/her work. Now, a lot can be said about increasing interactivity. After all, it benefits "the establishment" to design for the needs of the user.
David Weinberger brings Charles' argument down to earth in Darwin. David argues that pure collaboration is undesirable and that there is a price to severing content and presentation. I'm just curious what David thinks that price is.
Charles Munat creates a compelling vision of web design. Charles argues that designers are stuck in control mode. All forms of creativity before the digital age were in a fixed space. The designer always had the illusion of controlling the design. But as Charles points out, that was never the case. Every creation has never truly replicated the designers intended presentation. Films in crappy theatres (one of my favorites), paintings with unintended lighting and muted TV commercials. What makes the internet different is it is truly interactive. It has the potential to illuminate the control put on viewers. It puts the audience and the creator in a conversation where the experience for the audience (or users) is truly democratic. Or so Charles would argue.
Or is this a pipe dream. I think the web makes this more possible. But not entirely possible. The designer is always in a sense going to control the user's experience. Every designer has a vision. And, I think, by definition that means they want to control how the audience views his/her work. Now, a lot can be said about increasing interactivity. After all, it benefits "the establishment" to design for the needs of the user.
David Weinberger brings Charles' argument down to earth in Darwin. David argues that pure collaboration is undesirable and that there is a price to severing content and presentation. I'm just curious what David thinks that price is.
January 18, 2002
MIA
Did Eric Norlin go Blogump? No posts since January 9th? Where is the fearless warrior of the Internet? Did he take on another fearless covert mission of his former self battling bin Laden's cronies in the trenches of Afghanistan? Or did he conspicuously disappear with that "funky chick that he met through a Colorado professional association?" Will we ever know? And if we did, would he have to kill us?
Did Eric Norlin go Blogump? No posts since January 9th? Where is the fearless warrior of the Internet? Did he take on another fearless covert mission of his former self battling bin Laden's cronies in the trenches of Afghanistan? Or did he conspicuously disappear with that "funky chick that he met through a Colorado professional association?" Will we ever know? And if we did, would he have to kill us?
January 15, 2002
Coaching Carousel
I remember the days when football in January used to be about playoffs. Dirt. Mud. Grud. The best of the best. Battling head to head. But it's the NFL and it's New Economy owners (e.g. Danny-Boy) have created something more of a As the World Turns than (read in NFL films voice) The Packers At Lambeau Field. Really, I thought the WWF was the soap opera for guys. No, no. It's the NFL. What's next. Check out the rumor mill.
I want my NFL. Not these Days of our Lives.
I remember the days when football in January used to be about playoffs. Dirt. Mud. Grud. The best of the best. Battling head to head. But it's the NFL and it's New Economy owners (e.g. Danny-Boy) have created something more of a As the World Turns than (read in NFL films voice) The Packers At Lambeau Field. Really, I thought the WWF was the soap opera for guys. No, no. It's the NFL. What's next. Check out the rumor mill.
I want my NFL. Not these Days of our Lives.
January 14, 2002
Spurrier Routs Schottenheimer
Joel Achenbach - How the rest of the NFL failed to land Spurrier while Danny-Boy goes for the bomb.
Joel Achenbach - How the rest of the NFL failed to land Spurrier while Danny-Boy goes for the bomb.
January 08, 2002
Does Advertising Even Work?
Market Profs asks this question and follows up with, if so, when and why. But we should be also asking how advertising works (or does that fit under why ...) There is so much focus on which type, which medium, which vehicle, which formula is best. What about good old creative? I truly believe advertising works, but it is becoming less effective for two reasons: There is increasingly more of it, and increasingly more of it sucks. Why? We are less engaged with customers. We don't connect, except in very few cases. There must be more attention paid to how we connect with customers. They are smarter and more cynical.
The article from MarketingProfs is a good start. But I think the answer to the question posed above runs much deeper.
Market Profs asks this question and follows up with, if so, when and why. But we should be also asking how advertising works (or does that fit under why ...) There is so much focus on which type, which medium, which vehicle, which formula is best. What about good old creative? I truly believe advertising works, but it is becoming less effective for two reasons: There is increasingly more of it, and increasingly more of it sucks. Why? We are less engaged with customers. We don't connect, except in very few cases. There must be more attention paid to how we connect with customers. They are smarter and more cynical.
The article from MarketingProfs is a good start. But I think the answer to the question posed above runs much deeper.
The Media Grok back with a New Face: Media Unspun
The editors and creator of the Industry Standard's Media Grok ezine are back. Of course International Media Group retained the naming rights to Media Gork and Industry Standard, but Jimmy Guterman promises the same quality as the original Grok. This is really what the new media journalisim needs ... I'm glad they're back.
The only bummer is they will be charging $40 for the subscription come March once it becomes a daily. I hope it works. But some have their doubts. Until March, though, I know I'll be eagerly awaiting. And who knows, maybe I'll chip in for a sub.
The editors and creator of the Industry Standard's Media Grok ezine are back. Of course International Media Group retained the naming rights to Media Gork and Industry Standard, but Jimmy Guterman promises the same quality as the original Grok. This is really what the new media journalisim needs ... I'm glad they're back.
The only bummer is they will be charging $40 for the subscription come March once it becomes a daily. I hope it works. But some have their doubts. Until March, though, I know I'll be eagerly awaiting. And who knows, maybe I'll chip in for a sub.
Bad Customer Service .... Right Back At Ya!
From Doc Searls' blog - the greatest complaint I've ever seen. This makes you want to jump up and shout, "yeh! one for the team!"
From Doc Searls' blog - the greatest complaint I've ever seen. This makes you want to jump up and shout, "yeh! one for the team!"
January 07, 2002
Gonzo Engaged - Real World Quesitons
There's a great thread going on a Gonzo Engaged about the profitability of Gonzo Marketing and how to gauge it's true value to a company. I'm not sure what stance I would take ... I really need time to go back through the thread. But Clay Shirky asks the question any sane business will ask and that we Gonzo Marketers need to have a business friendly answer for ... can a company utilize Gonzo Marketing, spend less money and get a better return: "If you tell P&G you have a way to sell more Jello, you'll be politely shown the door. If you tell them you have a way to sell more Jello for the same money they're spending now, you'll be told to take a number. Only if you tell them you have a way to sell more Jello for less than they are spending now will you be ushered into the marketing directors office."
to be continued ...
There's a great thread going on a Gonzo Engaged about the profitability of Gonzo Marketing and how to gauge it's true value to a company. I'm not sure what stance I would take ... I really need time to go back through the thread. But Clay Shirky asks the question any sane business will ask and that we Gonzo Marketers need to have a business friendly answer for ... can a company utilize Gonzo Marketing, spend less money and get a better return: "If you tell P&G you have a way to sell more Jello, you'll be politely shown the door. If you tell them you have a way to sell more Jello for the same money they're spending now, you'll be told to take a number. Only if you tell them you have a way to sell more Jello for less than they are spending now will you be ushered into the marketing directors office."
to be continued ...
The Media Monopoly & The Big Ten
Chris Locke directs us to a great article and chart from The Nation about the monopolizing of information sources. Honestly, only skimmed the article, but I want to put it here to explor later in greater depth.
Chris Locke directs us to a great article and chart from The Nation about the monopolizing of information sources. Honestly, only skimmed the article, but I want to put it here to explor later in greater depth.
The Truth About Asking too Many Questions
This is a great article by Dev Bhatia at ClickZ on the New York Times' attempt to collect more data from its online registrants. I've always heard and intunitively known the more questions, and more personal the questions, one asks (no matter how valuable their brand is, i.e. NYT) it doesn't make much web sense.
From the article:
Instead of asking the registrants for the answers to these questions, what if The Times had gone to a third-party data bureau and simply appended this data to its files? Demographic data of this sort is a commodity and can be had for pennies per record. Had The Times done this, it would likely have gotten more accurate data, because appended data is much more likely to be accurate than online-form data, which is notoriously unreliable. So, it could have expected to raise the price of future advertising even higher. In addition, The Times would not have suffered from the drop-off in conversion rates, which occurs when too many questions are asked.
In economic terms, The Times could expect to make more advertising dollars in the future by measuring its cost as the cost of appended data rather than that of lost registrants. It would be creating revenues without harming its asset. Clearly, The Times's online enterprise is valued by its total number of subscribers.
This is a great article by Dev Bhatia at ClickZ on the New York Times' attempt to collect more data from its online registrants. I've always heard and intunitively known the more questions, and more personal the questions, one asks (no matter how valuable their brand is, i.e. NYT) it doesn't make much web sense.
From the article:
Instead of asking the registrants for the answers to these questions, what if The Times had gone to a third-party data bureau and simply appended this data to its files? Demographic data of this sort is a commodity and can be had for pennies per record. Had The Times done this, it would likely have gotten more accurate data, because appended data is much more likely to be accurate than online-form data, which is notoriously unreliable. So, it could have expected to raise the price of future advertising even higher. In addition, The Times would not have suffered from the drop-off in conversion rates, which occurs when too many questions are asked.
In economic terms, The Times could expect to make more advertising dollars in the future by measuring its cost as the cost of appended data rather than that of lost registrants. It would be creating revenues without harming its asset. Clearly, The Times's online enterprise is valued by its total number of subscribers.
January 04, 2002
POELog Links To Hyper-Conversations
Thanks Rob Poel for linking to my blog .... you're the first that I know of. Check out Rob's Blog.
Thanks Rob Poel for linking to my blog .... you're the first that I know of. Check out Rob's Blog.
January 03, 2002
Google's 2001 Zeitgest
Nostradamus is the big winner this year. Honorable mentions go to: World Trade Center, Anna Kournikova, CNN, Osama Bin Laden and Harry Potter. The big losers are: Election Results, Pokemon, the Olympics.
Nostradamus is the big winner this year. Honorable mentions go to: World Trade Center, Anna Kournikova, CNN, Osama Bin Laden and Harry Potter. The big losers are: Election Results, Pokemon, the Olympics.
January 02, 2002
The Adventures of Cy Netson
Year: 2084
Place: Somewhere in the Mid West
Cy: Mom, what is that symbol?
Mom: What symbol?
Cy: Everytime I get mail, this squarish thing with a triangle in the middle pops up on my Com.
Mom: That's what they called an envelope.
Cy: What's an envelope?
Mom: When I was just a little girl we used to receive messages on paper. They were enclosed in an envelope and delivered to a physical box, we called a mail box. You would call it an inbox. All the companies couldn't afford to keep sending mail.
Cy: How much did it cost?
Mom: I could send your grandmother a letter for $3.17.
Cy: Grandmother didn't have a Com?
Mom: No, she came from a different generation.
Year: 2084
Place: Somewhere in the Mid West
Cy: Mom, what is that symbol?
Mom: What symbol?
Cy: Everytime I get mail, this squarish thing with a triangle in the middle pops up on my Com.
Mom: That's what they called an envelope.
Cy: What's an envelope?
Mom: When I was just a little girl we used to receive messages on paper. They were enclosed in an envelope and delivered to a physical box, we called a mail box. You would call it an inbox. All the companies couldn't afford to keep sending mail.
Cy: How much did it cost?
Mom: I could send your grandmother a letter for $3.17.
Cy: Grandmother didn't have a Com?
Mom: No, she came from a different generation.
Happy New Year!
I'm ready to kick some butt in 2002! Starting with making my Q1 goals, losing 40 lbs and kicking my career in the upward direction (this plateau has worn out its welcome!).
Another good Gonzo Review.
Locke's Cluetrain cohort, David Weinberger, reviews Gonzo on Darwin.
Dot.Bomb
I got Sean Carton's Dot.Bomb Survival Guide for Christmas this year. So far, I'm enjoying the read. Lot's of facts and figures backed up with Sean's web sense. So far, the only thing I don't like is I wish Sean would put in more analysis. Because when he does, it's right on.
I'm ready to kick some butt in 2002! Starting with making my Q1 goals, losing 40 lbs and kicking my career in the upward direction (this plateau has worn out its welcome!).
Another good Gonzo Review.
Locke's Cluetrain cohort, David Weinberger, reviews Gonzo on Darwin.
Dot.Bomb
I got Sean Carton's Dot.Bomb Survival Guide for Christmas this year. So far, I'm enjoying the read. Lot's of facts and figures backed up with Sean's web sense. So far, the only thing I don't like is I wish Sean would put in more analysis. Because when he does, it's right on.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
